Current:Home > ContactAdnan Syed goes before Maryland Supreme Court facing ‘specter of reincarceration,’ his lawyers say -Thrive Capital Insights
Adnan Syed goes before Maryland Supreme Court facing ‘specter of reincarceration,’ his lawyers say
View
Date:2025-04-27 16:56:38
ANNAPOLIS, Md. (AP) — Attorneys for Adnan Syed, who is now free after being imprisoned more than two decades ago for the murder of his ex-girlfriend, will once again be arguing to keep his freedom in a case known to millions by the true-crime podcast “Serial.”
In a case fraught with legal twists and divided court rulings, arguments are set to begin Thursday in Maryland’s Supreme Court. Syed’s attorneys are appealing the reinstatement of his murder conviction by an appellate court, in a case that has broader ramification’s for victim’s rights as well as Syed’s future.
Syed, 42, was released from prison in September 2022, when a Baltimore judge overturned his conviction. City prosecutors had dropped all charges after finding flaws in the evidence.
However, in March, the Appellate Court of Maryland ordered a redo of the hearing that enabled Syed to walk out a free man. The appellate court said the victim’s family didn’t receive adequate notice to attend the hearing in person, violating their right to be “treated with dignity and respect.”
The family of Hae Min Lee also is appealing to the state’s highest court, contending that crime victims in Maryland have a right to be heard and challenge the evidence in hearings like the one last year that vacated Syed’s conviction from 2000.
He faces at least the potential of being sent back to prison, a point his lawyers raised in court filings.
“The terrifying specter of reincarceration has hung over Mr. Syed’s head every day for the past ten months,” Syed’s lawyer, Erica Suter, wrote in a brief filed with the court in August.
The case could have consequences for victims’ rights. Although the appellate court ruled that Lee’s brother didn’t get sufficient notice to attend the hearing that vacated Syed’s conviction, the court also said state law doesn’t guarantee crime victims a “right to be heard” during the hearings. That decision falls to the presiding judge. Allowing victims to present evidence or otherwise engage substantively would “result in a huge shift in practice,” the judges said.
The Maryland Supreme Court isn’t expected to issue a ruling on Thursday. A written ruling will be filed on the court’s website, although it’s unclear when.
Syed’s attorneys say the Lee family did have sufficient notice about the hearing. They also argue that the family’s appeal is moot, because prosecutors decided not to charge Syed again after his conviction was vacated. His attorneys contend that even if the rights of Lee’s brother, Young Lee, were violated, he hasn’t demonstrated whether the alleged violation would have changed the hearing’s outcome.
Lee, who ended up speaking remotely at the hearing, was notified on a Friday afternoon that it would take place the following Monday. That was “insufficient time to reasonably allow Mr. Lee, who lived in California, to attend the hearing in person,” the appellate court ruled. Attorneys for Lee’s family have criticized a lack of transparency as well in the court proceedings that led to Syed’s release.
“Hae Min Lee’s murder has been at issue in Maryland’s courts for nearly a generation,” David Sanford, an attorney for the family, wrote in a court filing last month. He argued the state Supreme Court should send the case to another judge to decide whether to vacate the conviction or not.
This isn’t the first time Maryland’s highest court has taken up Syed’s protracted legal odyssey.
In 2019, a divided court ruled 4-3 to deny Syed a new trial. While the court agreed with a lower court that Syed’s legal counsel was deficient in failing to investigate an alibi witness, it disagreed that the deficiency prejudiced the case. That ruling came after a lower court ordered a retrial in 2016 on grounds that Syed’s attorney, Cristina Gutierrez, who died in 2004, didn’t contact an alibi witness and provided ineffective counsel.
In November 2019, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review the decision by Maryland’s top court.
More recently, Baltimore prosecutors went over Syed’s files under a Maryland law targeting so-called “juvenile lifers” because he was 17 when Hae Min Lee was found strangled to death and buried in a makeshift grave.
Prosecutors uncovered numerous problems, including alternative suspects and the unreliable evidence of cellphone tower data presented at trial. Instead of reconsidering his sentence, prosecutors filed a motion to vacate Syed’s conviction entirely.
veryGood! (459)
Related
- Carolinas bracing for second landfall from Tropical Storm Debby: Live updates
- Stop Right Now and Read Victoria Beckham’s Birthday Note to “Loving Daughter in Law” Nicola Peltz Beckham
- Oprah Winfrey denies Taraji P. Henson feud after actress made pay disparity comments
- Congo’s constitutional court upholds election results, declares President Tshisekedi the winner
- A New York Appellate Court Rejects a Broad Application of the State’s Green Amendment
- Hottest year ever, what can be done? Plenty: more renewables and nuclear, less methane and meat
- Supreme Court rejects appeal by ex-officer Tou Thao, who held back crowd as George Floyd lay dying
- Selena Gomez Reveals What She Actually Told Taylor Swift at Golden Globes
- Report: Lauri Markkanen signs 5-year, $238 million extension with Utah Jazz
- Virginia police identify suspect in 3 cold-case homicides from the 1980s, including victims of the Colonial Parkway Murders
Ranking
- Retirement planning: 3 crucial moves everyone should make before 2025
- Animal shelters are overwhelmed by abandoned dogs. Here's why.
- Jennifer Lopez laughs off 'Sad Affleck' memes, says Ben is 'happy'
- Finding a remote job is getting harder, especially if you want a high-earning job
- A steeplechase record at the 2024 Paris Olympics. Then a proposal. (He said yes.)
- Secret tunnel in NYC synagogue leads to brawl between police and worshippers
- Hezbollah launches drone strike on base in northern Israel. Israel’s military says there’s no damage
- A new wave of violence sweeps across Ecuador after a gang leader’s apparent escape from prison
Recommendation
IOC's decision to separate speed climbing from other disciplines paying off
Former Pakistani prime minister Khan and his wife are indicted in a graft case
Eclectic Grandpa Is the New Aesthetic & We Are Here for the Cozy Quirkiness
GE business to fill order for turbines to power Western Hemisphere’s largest wind project
Spooky or not? Some Choa Chu Kang residents say community garden resembles cemetery
Ex-Green Beret stands with Venezuelan coup plotter ahead of U.S. sentencing on terror charges
Lisa Bonet files for divorce from estranged husband Jason Momoa following separation
Kremlin foe Navalny says he’s been put in a punishment cell in an Arctic prison colony